SOC 2 Type 1 vs Type 2: Which Report Will Your Customers Accept?
Harsh
Cybersecurity Experts
Table of Contents
- 01SOC 2 Type 1 vs Type 2: the difference in one paragraph
- 02Comparison table
- 03What a SOC 2 Type 1 report tells a customer
- 04What a SOC 2 Type 2 report adds
- 05Which report will your customers accept?
- 06When to start with Type 1
- 07When to go straight to Type 2
- 08SOC 2 Type 1 readiness: what to have in place
- 09Moving from Type 1 to Type 2
- 10SOC 2 Type I and II: a note on naming
- 11How Digisecuritas supports both reports
- 12Plan the right report for your customers
- 13Frequently Asked Questions
SOC 2 Type 1 vs Type 2: the difference in one paragraph
A SOC 2 Type 1 report gives an auditor's opinion on whether your controls are suitably designed at a single point in time. A SOC 2 Type 2 report gives an opinion on design and on whether those controls operated effectively over a period, commonly 3 to 12 months. Type 1 says the controls exist. Type 2 says they worked, with test results to show it.
Both reports are issued by an independent licensed CPA firm against the AICPA Trust Services Criteria. The choice between them usually comes down to what your customers will accept and how soon you need something to show them.
Comparison table
SOC 2 Type 1 | SOC 2 Type 2
| |
|---|---|---|
What the auditor assesses | Design of controls | Design and operating effectiveness |
Time covered | One date | A period, commonly 3 to 12 months |
Evidence | Policies, configurations and one example of each control | Samples drawn from across the whole period |
Includes test results | No | Yes, a section listing each test and its outcome |
Time to obtain | Shorter, since there is no observation period | Longer, because the period has to pass first |
Typical use | First report, early deals, proof of progress | Enterprise procurement, renewals, regulated buyers |
Customer acceptance | Often accepted as an interim step | The standard most enterprise buyers ask for |
What a SOC 2 Type 1 report tells a customer
A Type 1 report contains management's description of the system, management's assertion and the auditor's opinion that the controls described were suitably designed as of a stated date.
It shows a buyer that you have defined a security program and that an independent CPA firm has reviewed it. It does not show that the access review you described happens every quarter. For a customer assessing a new vendor, that is a start. For a customer about to hand over sensitive data at scale, it is usually not sufficient alone.
What a SOC 2 Type 2 report adds
A SOC 2 Type 2 report includes everything in a Type 1 and adds a section with the auditor's tests of each control and the results. The auditor samples evidence from across the review period: new hires onboarded in month two, a code change deployed in month four, an access review completed in month five.
If a control failed during the period, the report says so as an exception. That detail is why security teams prefer Type 2. They can read how your controls performed over months, including where they slipped.
Which report will your customers accept?
In the SOC 2 Type 1 vs Type 2 decision, the answer depends on who is asking.
Startups and mid-market buyers often accept a Type 1, or a Type 1 with a commitment to deliver Type 2 by a date.
Enterprise procurement teams generally ask for Type 2. Many will accept Type 1 for a first contract if a Type 2 is underway.
Regulated industries such as financial services, healthcare and insurance expect Type 2, sometimes with criteria beyond Security.
Renewals almost always require a current Type 2, because by then you have had time to produce one.
The reliable way to find out is to ask. Email the buyer's security contact: "Would a Type 1 report satisfy your requirement for signing, with a Type 2 to follow?" Their answer decides your path.
When to start with Type 1
Type 1 makes sense when:
A deal depends on showing a report in the next few months
Your controls are new and have no operating history yet
You want an auditor's view of your control design before committing to a long review period
The customer has confirmed Type 1 is acceptable
When to go straight to Type 2
Skipping Type 1 makes sense when:
No deal is waiting on an immediate report
Your controls have already been running for several months
Your customers have said they will only accept Type 2
You want to avoid paying for two examinations in one year
Some companies choose a short first Type 2 period, such as three months, to get a Type 2 report sooner. Check with your buyers first, since some want to see at least six months.
SOC 2 Type 1 readiness: what to have in place
SOC 2 Type 1 readiness means your controls are designed, documented and implemented by the report date. Before the auditor arrives you need:
A defined system boundary and a written system description
Selected Trust Services Criteria, with Security as the required one
A risk assessment
Approved policies for access, change management, incident response, vendor management and related areas
Technical controls configured: multifactor authentication, logging, encryption, backups, endpoint protection
Named control owners
At least one piece of evidence showing each control exists
A readiness assessment checks these and lists the gaps before the CPA firm does.
Moving from Type 1 to Type 2
The usual sequence is to close gaps, obtain the Type 1 report and start the Type 2 review period immediately after the Type 1 date. From then on, controls have to run on schedule and leave evidence every time.
Most exceptions in a first Type 2 come from missed routines. An access review skipped in one quarter. A departed employee whose account stayed active for two weeks. A change deployed without a recorded approval. None is a security disaster, and each appears in the report your customer reads. Quarterly internal checks during the period catch these while there is still time to correct course.
SOC 2 Type I and II: a note on naming
You will see the reports written as SOC 2 Type I and II with Roman numerals, and as Type 1 and Type 2. They are the same reports. The AICPA uses Arabic numerals in current guidance, and both forms are common in contracts and questionnaires.
How Digisecuritas supports both reports
Digisecuritas prepares companies for Type 1 and Type 2 examinations: scoping and criteria selection, the readiness assessment, control design and mapping, evidence review, readiness testing and examination preparation. The examination is performed by an independent CPA firm. For Type 2, we help teams keep evidence on track across the review period. Details are on the SOC 2 readiness page.
Plan the right report for your customers
Tell us which customers are asking and when. We will help you decide between Type 1 and Type 2 and lay out the steps to get there.
